Sue,
I sit firmly on the fence a lot of the time, and don't often post on here, however the "stuff" so far mentioned by this Mr Underwood has been totally negative. If he has been in touch with so many people why didn't he say that before my query. He previously implied that volunteers couldn't be found in the winter, but I know plenty of groups that are active all year round. Now he seems to be retracting his comment; a typical journalistic trick.
Whilst we all may have some doubts about how the new Charity is going to cope and manage things, it is no good just criticising it. These negatives need to be covered by some ideas on how it is thought it should be done. All we seem to be getting from Mr Underwood is "It won't work", but what is needed is an explanation of why and how he/they think it should be done.