My one experience of fitting a new outboard impeller was not good. The supplied replacement impeller was a very tight fit on the shaft, and I hadn't really twigged that it was important for it to be able to 'float'. It was a good while ago now, so I can't remember the details, but the end result was some sort of seizure within the drive train after maybe 15 minutes' running. Nothing that couldn't be fixed by pulling it all apart again, and easing the fit of the impeller on the shaft, but a bl**dy nuisance at the time.
Tim