That's fair comment Natalie, and while I was wide of the mark, it backs up what I was trying to say. You can't justify a CCer or any other visitor to an area paying council tax on the basis they get council services, and selective examples like hygiene checks at pubs and restaurants aren't helpful.
and Council Tax doesn't pay for canals except in a few instances, so a resident does walk the canal for free, unless they pay income tax (a different issue) they have not contributed
I know some people (Carlt for example) favour local income tax, as do I in principle, but it has the same issue, you pay it where you live to the authority you live in. If you use the facilities of another authority, you haven't paid for them, and there are fewer available.
To put it bluntly, it is impossible for someone who doesn't live in a locality to pay a local tax except, possibly, local sales tax, and I don't think we have that (leaving congestion charge and car park charges out of it).