Skip to content

Bad surveys and Tidal rivers

Featured Replies

#1

A cautionary tale while the boat sunk outside West Stockwith lock is still an ongoing issue..

I was recently asked to move a boat from Keadby lock to Cromwell on the tidal Trent. It had been bought a couple of weeks earlier, with a full survey that didn't highlight any structural problems.

The new owners were onboard for the trip and became concerned the cabin floor was getting "very wet from underneath", to the point that they were bailing out from a cupboard by the front doors.

After pulling up at Dunham pontoon it was discovered that the gas locker floor was rotten, water had been coming in through the drain holes and pouring straight into the bilge.

The bottles were stood on a rubber mat and I'd guess the surveyor didn't even lift it to inspect the steel underneath. When I did it was obvious the mat and paint stuck to it were the only thing holding it all together.

After rigging the bilge pump up in cabin and blocking the drain holes we continued to Cromwell, but with a couple of hours left and had there been nobody on board things could have ended very differently.

#2

Whose survey was it - the previous owner's or the new owners'? If the latter I hope they went back to their surveyor to let them know what happened.

It sounds like your title is wrong - was it a bad survey or a bad surveyor?

A surveyor can't test every square inch of a hull, but the gas locker floor is a key area that should have been checked.

Edited by blackrose

  • Author
#3

It was the new owners pre purchase survey. I urged them to take action against the surveyor as it was black and white what had been missed, but they didn't seem keen. I don't think they realised how much damage had already been caused.

#4
24 minutes ago, noddyboater said:

It was the new owners pre purchase survey. I urged them to take action against the surveyor as it was black and white what had been missed, but they didn't seem keen. I don't think they realised how much damage had already been caused.

They must in the least inform the BMF which probably oversees the surveyor if they don't wish to take action against the surveyor themselves.

  • Author
#5

Maybe they will take some action when the bill for repair arrives.

I didn't recognise the name of the surveyor, but it was done at the busy yard in Thorne, where a lot of craning in and out takes place.

#6
39 minutes ago, noddyboater said:

Maybe they will take some action when the bill for repair arrives.

I didn't recognise the name of the surveyor, but it was done at the busy yard in Thorne, where a lot of craning in and out takes place.

But that busy yard has nothing to do with the surveyor’s incompetence, unless they instructed the buyers to use said surveyor?

You need to name the surveyor, not where the boat was surveyed, as the yard is unlikely to know about the defects you’ve mentioned.

Edited by BoatingLifeUpNorth2

#7

I'm increasingly thinking that having a bilge pump at the back of the cabin bilge is the way to go. Having been there myself (thankfully only a leak from the water tank), having water rising through your floor is rather scary on a canal, let alone on the tidal Trent! Not sure why every boat doesn't have one tbh.

#8

Alarming. I would hope that any surveyor would pick up on a holed/damaged/weak gas locker floor. It's a 'known issue' and one of the things that BSS surveyors have to check as there have been a number of incidents.

#9

The surveyors planned defence (when I attempted to take one to court) was that "the suvey is only valid until the time he walks away from the boat".

He can take no responsibilty for its condition afterwards as anyone could have come along and knocked/drill holes in it, disconnect gas pipes etc etc.

The contract small print also says that he will not lift carpets etc or disconnect or remove anything (such as a gas cylinder)

My solicitor told me to drop the case as not only would my costs be huge, I'd lose, and have to pay all of the surveyors costs as well.

However, the suggestion to reporting him to his 'surveyors body' or BM is valid, but remember, that to work as a boat surveyor, there are no mandatory qualifications needed , and no requirements to be registered, or a member of a professional body. Anyone can print a business card saying "Marine Surveyor".

#10
2 minutes ago, Alan de Enfield said:

The surveyors planned defence (when I attempted to take one to court) was that "the suvey is only valid until the time he walks away from the boat".

He can take no responsibilty for its condition afterwards as anyone could have come along and knocked/drill holes in it, disconnect gas pipes etc etc.

The contract small print also says that he will not lift carpets etc or disconnect or remove anything (such as a gas cylinder)

My solicitor told me to drop the case as not only would my costs be huge, I'd lose, and have to pay all of the surveyors costs as well.

However, the suggestion to reporting him to his 'surveyors body' or BM is valid, but remember, that to work as a boat surveyor, there are no mandatory qualifications needed , and no requirements to be registered, or a member of a professional body. Anyone can print a business card saying "Marine Surveyor".

That's the same as for a house survey, which is why they're more or less an expensive waste of time. They won't even move a picture on a wall to check for damp. I've always assumed boat surveys are the same. The surveyor certainly wouldn't heave gas bottles about. I suppose if there was an out of water survey he might have checked underneath, but only if it was accessible. How do they usually check base plate thickness?

  • Author
#11
29 minutes ago, Arthur Marshall said:

That's the same as for a house survey, which is why they're more or less an expensive waste of time. They won't even move a picture on a wall to check for damp. I've always assumed boat surveys are the same. The surveyor certainly wouldn't heave gas bottles about. I suppose if there was an out of water survey he might have checked underneath, but only if it was accessible. How do they usually check base plate thickness?

It was an out of the water survey, anything else is pointless and a waste of money.

I'd suggest that a surveyor who can't be bothered to check the integrity of a gas locker should find a new career.

Moving a loose 13kg cylinder isn't difficult.

#12
30 minutes ago, Arthur Marshall said:

That's the same as for a house survey, which is why they're more or less an expensive waste of time. They won't even move a picture on a wall to check for damp. I've always assumed boat surveys are the same. The surveyor certainly wouldn't heave gas bottles about. I suppose if there was an out of water survey he might have checked underneath, but only if it was accessible. How do they usually check base plate thickness?

I dont ever have boat or house surveys including this house I recently bought. It hasnt fallen over since 1870 so I think it will out live me. Its personal preference of course.

#13

This doesn't inspire confidence. Would it make sense to ensure that any boat surveyor is registered with a professional body before hiring them? Possibly the YDSA or some other? I just goggled it.

#14
2 hours ago, phantom_iv said:

I'm increasingly thinking that having a bilge pump at the back of the cabin bilge is the way to go. Having been there myself (thankfully only a leak from the water tank), having water rising through your floor is rather scary on a canal, let alone on the tidal Trent! Not sure why every boat doesn't have one tbh.

Because 99+% of the time it isn't needed. Chances are that if you did need it in anger after it had been sitting unused for years, it might have seized up or something else gone wrong. Unless you are deliberately going to tip a few buckets of water into the bilge and pump it out again a couple of times a year.

Edited by David Mack

#15
2 hours ago, David Mack said:

Chances are that if you did need it in anger after it had been sitting unused for years, it might have seized up or something else gone wrong.

This is why the first thing I do upon arriving at the boat, and the last thing I do before I go home, is switch the bilge pump on for a few seconds. It doesn't ensure the auto function will work but at least I know it's not seized up. It's one of the items in the "before going home" tick list on my phone (using Microsoft's free To Do app).

#16

A friends boat had a gas locker floor which was found to be perforated by corrosion a quite correctly identified as a BSS failure point. So I immediately checked my own , which was okay. But I applied some sheep dip (as I have heard it called ) as a precaution.

image.png

#17
3 hours ago, ushfuhg said:

This doesn't inspire confidence. Would it make sense to ensure that any boat surveyor is registered with a professional body before hiring them? Possibly the YDSA or some other? I just goggled it.

It MAY help a little but, they will still have the 'standard T&Cs' which mean "anything they miss is not their fault" !

A survey may find enough problems to allow you to re-negotiate the price, OR, it may miss something important that'll cost your "£ thousands"

It's a gamble - do you feel lucky ?

#18
5 hours ago, phantom_iv said:

I'm increasingly thinking that having a bilge pump at the back of the cabin bilge is the way to go. Having been there myself (thankfully only a leak from the water tank), having water rising through your floor is rather scary on a canal, let alone on the tidal Trent! Not sure why every boat doesn't have one tbh.

It was a requirement of the RCD that "all major bilge areas" (it's been a while since I was involved so this may not be the exact wording) should have a bilge pump installed so any boatbuilder who signs the boat off as RCD compliant if it doesn't have one is telling porkies.

#19
15 minutes ago, davidg said:

It was a requirement of the RCD that "all major bilge areas" (it's been a while since I was involved so this may not be the exact wording) should have a bilge pump installed so any boatbuilder who signs the boat off as RCD compliant if it doesn't have one is telling porkies.

Hardly a worry, our second narrow didn't have a bilge pump when we sold it at 16 years old and our current one got to 20 years old before I fitted 2.

#20
19 minutes ago, davidg said:

so any boatbuilder who signs the boat off as RCD compliant if it doesn't have one is telling porkies.

So, add it to the list - for example - is 22 non compliances any worse than 21 non-compliances ?

#21
18 minutes ago, davidg said:

It was a requirement of the RCD that "all major bilge areas" (it's been a while since I was involved so this may not be the exact wording) should have a bilge pump installed so any boatbuilder who signs the boat off as RCD compliant if it doesn't have one is telling porkies.

What do they class as “Major bilge areas”?

#22
4 minutes ago, BoatingLifeUpNorth2 said:

What do they class as “Major bilge areas”?

Yes, good question which I never fully resolved. On a boat with a trad engine room you could end up with four separate bilges:

1) In front of the front engine room bulkhead

2 & 3) Either side of the welded in engine beds

4) Under the back cabin behind the stern engine room bulkhead

Anyone want to add any more?

Under the well deck in front of the cabin bulkhead perhaps?

The engine drip tray between the engine beds? (not sure how this sits with anti-pollution regs)

T'was a minefield.

#23
18 minutes ago, davidg said:

Yes, good question which I never fully resolved. On a boat with a trad engine room you could end up with four separate bilges:

1) In front of the front engine room bulkhead

2 & 3) Either side of the welded in engine beds

4) Under the back cabin behind the stern engine room bulkhead

Anyone want to add any more?

Under the well deck in front of the cabin bulkhead perhaps?

The engine drip tray between the engine beds? (not sure how this sits with anti-pollution regs)

T'was a minefield.

You can’t have one under the engine, as you say to prevent oil/diesel being pumped into the canal. If you need one anywhere where oil could be pumped into the canal you need filters so all contaminants are removed before discharging into the water. That’s basically how I understand it.

#24
2 hours ago, BoatingLifeUpNorth2 said:

You can’t have one under the engine, as you say to prevent oil/diesel being pumped into the canal. If you need one anywhere where oil could be pumped into the canal you need filters so all contaminants are removed before discharging into the water. That’s basically how I understand it.

And, as it happens who has one for sale that does exacty that (a bilge pump that filters out oil and contaminents as it pumps).........................

RCR

#25
31 minutes ago, Alan de Enfield said:

And, as it happens who has one for sale that does exacty that (a bilge pump that filters out oil and contaminents as it pumps).........................

RCR

I wonder what happens when the filter gets saturated with oil, does the pump stop and the boat sink?

Create an account or sign in to comment

Recently Browsing 0

  • No registered users viewing this page.

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.