No, what I was trying to say, and obviously put badly, was that there was something about the manner of the post that raised my hackles, completely independently of the argument he was offering. I am still not saying whether I agree with the substance of his statement, just that it carried a strange overtone that predisposed me to judge his message harshly.
Some others on here have this talent also, to a lesser degree. They make statements that I find to be highly accurate but in a manner that leave me wanting to disagree. Some others have the opposite talent, they make statements that are more or less acceptable but do so with a generosity of spirit that makes me want to agree with them!
Ok, these are nuances that are not significant in the grand scheme of things, but I find it interesting.