Mod's hat time ...
It's a good debate and some interesting points have been raised. What I do want you to think about, is the wording of your posts. Nothing is proven or disproven other than money was owed and a boat taken to another place. Beyond that, we can surmise, infer, suggest or posit amongst many other useful terms, but we cannot say exactly. To suggest that one party has committed a crime is a serious allegation, however, the other party cannot refute this because they are not represented. Moreover, can I suggest that m'learned friend might not take too kindly to hearing that an ongoing case had been freely discussed in an open place. We rely on 'the conversation in the pub' rule often here, but I think we're going well beyond it with allegations of crimes being committed.
I am going to leave the thread open, because it is, in the main, important and useful, but please consider what you post, particularly where you are involved as advisors and as friends. If the content continues in the same manner as prior to this post, I will be taking sanctions against those who bring the forum into disrepute or who are vexatious.
Wriggly